Downsize or Keep the $520,000 Paid Off House at 66
Hank and June have a paid-off $520,000 house in Columbus, Ohio. June wants to sell and buy a $340,000 condo. Hank wants to stay. We followed both choices for 20 years — property tax, insurance, upkeep, HOA fees, selling costs and investment returns — then tested them against every 20-year period since 1928.
The short answer: downsizing came out about $352,000 ahead — but only if the $135,100 it frees up stays invested. Spend it, and it's roughly a tie.
Inputs: home $520,000 · property tax 1.47% of value (Franklin County) · house insurance $2,065/yr (Columbus avg) · condo HOA $222/mo (2011 Columbus median, inflation-adjusted) · condo insurance $650/yr (assumption) · selling costs 5.5% commission + 1.5% closing · moving $1,700 · condo buyer closing 2% (assumption).
Chapters
0:00 Stay or sell?
0:39 Our numbers
2:24 What a paid-off house really costs
4:02 What downsizing actually frees up
6:28 What really decides it
7:41 Tested since 1928
8:39 The verdict
9:37 What would change the answer
10:41 Your house, your numbers
Assumptions (labelled on screen): condo $340,000; inflation 2.5%/yr; home prices +3.5%/yr; invested money 5%/yr; house upkeep 1.5% of value/yr; condo upkeep 0.5%/yr. Not modelled: utilities, taxes on investment returns, and what the house means to you.
Sources
Franklin County, OH effective property tax rate (2024 ACS): propertytaxbystate.com/ohio/franklin-county
Ohio homeowners insurance, Columbus average (2026): nerdwallet.com/article/insurance/homeowners-insurance-ohio
Costs of selling a home (2026): homelight.com/blog/what-fees-are-associated-with-selling-a-house · opendoor.com/articles/heres-how-much-it-costs-to-sell-a-house
Home sale gain exclusion: IRS Publication 523 — irs.gov/publications/p523
Columbus condo fees (American Housing Survey 2011): caionline.org/getmedia/af78f8ca-b159-40c1-8177-f9287b0a68fb/ohiocondostats.pdf
Consumer Price Index: Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis — minneapolisfed.org/about-us/monetary-policy/inflation-calculator/consumer-price-index-1913-
Historical returns 1928–2025: Damodaran, NYU Stern — pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar/New_Home_Page/datafile/histretSP.html
Hank and June are animated characters with AI-generated voices. Numbers are computed from the sources above. Corrections go in the pinned comment.
Education only — not financial, tax or legal advice. For your situation, talk to a fee-only advisor.
#retirement #downsizing #retirementplanning
コメント 読み込み中…